Monday, July 12, 2004

the next battle

JCA writes passionately about something I think about a lot these days: motherhood and career.

Halfway through last semester, my employment discrimination professor brought in a guest professor to speak to us about gender discrimination in the workplace. At the time I was almost three months pregnant and trying to adjust to pregnancy and the rather enthusiastic hormonal mix that had taken hold of my emotions.

The guest professor, who specializes in gender discrimination, spoke about stereotype studies and women in the workplace. The professor described studies in which participants were asked to rate the intelligence of various fictional characters in an effort to determine the pervasiveness of gender stereotypes. The good news reflects JCA's experience: the fictional professional woman with no children had a perceived intelligence and capacity almost equal to that of the fictional professional man. (No study showed the man and woman exactly equal, but they were extremely close.)

However, once the woman was turned into a mother – but her described characteristics did not otherwise change – her perceived intelligence dropped precipitously. In one entirely depressing study, the fictional woman with children was slotted into the same intelligence stereotype category as the the physically handicapped, the blind, and the very old, groups that themselves suffer from horrendously bad publicity as far as perceived capacity. There was only one poor group that consistently rated lower in perceived intelligence: stay-at-home mothers.

I almost started crying in class.

There is so much to love right now. I love being pregnant, watching my body change, my husband's transformation into a father. I love this new little person kicking around inside me ferociously.

But I hate the stifling societal straitjackets that come with parenthood. I hate that no matter what choices my husband and I make, a large segment of society will continually question those choices. I hate the fact that I even have to worry about this, that these outdated stereotypes will affect my life, my husband's life, and my son's life.

On the other hand, the best choices I've made in my life have always been those made in contravention to popular and uncreative wisdom. I didn't cry that day, and since that class, I've come to secretly relish the people who sniff mournfully and disapprovingly, "I would never do that!" I respond politely, but I think, "I'm sure you wouldn't." And I smile.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

I am among the "lowest of the low", so to speak, the stay-at-home-moms brigade! I have gotten used to this disdain over the last 2 1/2 years, and just let it roll off my back. My beautiful 3 1/2 year-old daughter is all the validation I need! Best of luck to you in this magical time:)

Anonymous said...

I am totally impressed with your attitude and your unwillingness to let small minded people and their outdated stereotypes affect how you see yourself and your family.

Stay at home parents (moms or dads) are a rare, but wonderful commodity.  My kids had that marvelous experience; indeed were home schooled throughout the elementary school years.  They have benefited greatly from that (which is not an attempt to assign any negative connotations to those parents who must (or choose) to work).  The reason they had such a benefit is *because* their mother was (is!) so smart.

Anonymous said...

I try not to let the disdain and rampant stereotyping get to me (and my husband does too). It's not always easy, and I'm sure it will be much harder once I have an actual baby here. But I refuse to give in without a fight!

Anonymous said...

I hear you. The judgment goes both ways, too. If you decide to work, there will be people judging you for not being a stay-at-home parent.

If you choose to stay home because that is what you want to do, people will think you are old fashioned and judge you for not "having it all". I know because it's something I deal with every day- people judging my wife for her decision to stay at home.

So whatever you decide to do, please don't judge the others.

Anonymous said...

This is a real issue and I'm sure that it foreshadows some of the challanges ahead for you. I have faith that will continue to excel because of who you are. It's not easy trying something different from the norm, but it will be worth it.

Anonymous said...

I admire you tremendously for your choice!  My  husband and I have been married over 11 years and still aren't interested in children, and I'm constantly wondering what's wrong with me.  I don't  think there's any reason to look down on women who choose children; I think there must be something wrong with me/us for not wanting them.  

-Shelley
The Menagerie

Anonymous said...

I don't think there is any problem with not having kids. I have plenty of friends who will never be parents. It's a very tough decision if you aren't one of the folks who have always known they want kids. If you want it, you'll know when the time comes.